Home Business Ryanair says it's not 'hiding' behind GDPR in US lawsuit

Ryanair says it’s not ‘hiding’ behind GDPR in US lawsuit

- Advertisement -

Ryanair has been accused of trying to hide behind EU data protection rules which, it has been claimed, would prevent it from having to disclose “vital information” in a US class action lawsuit linked to a pilot-rostering debacle at the airline in 2017.

The carrier has strenuously denied the allegation.

An Alabama pension fund for fire officers and police officers sued Ryanair and group chief executive Michael O’Leary in 2018, claiming they had made false and misleading statements to shareholders regarding employment issues at the airline.

The pension fund also alleged that increased costs as a result of unionisation at the carrier, coupled with lower profits, wiped out “millions” in shareholder value. Ryanair and Mr O’Leary reject the claims.

In June, they failed to have the case dismissed, but the presiding judge said that many of the complaints made against the defendants don’t have any actionable basis.

The parties in the case have been attempting to thrash out a mutually acceptable protective order that would be applied to sensitive information during the case.

Lawyers for the pension fund claimed that the defendants have insisted that any such order would permit the party producing documents to redact any information defined as “foreign personal data”, even if such information would normally be discoverable under US rules.

“Defendants claim that the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation requires that employee names and other professional contact information be redacted from discovery material to protect the privacy interests of its EU citizens,” the lawyers for the pension fund have told the New York court.

“However, adopting such an approach would allow defendants to unilaterally withhold vital information from lead plaintiffs,” they argued. “Indeed, defendants have been unwilling to confirm that they will not redact even basic, but critical, information related to lead plaintiffs’ claims, including names, email addresses, and job titles, from communications they produce.”

But lawyers for Ryanair and Mr O’Leary have accused the plaintiff of seeking a “categorical ruling” from the court that the defendants should not be given any opportunity to comply with applicable foreign data privacy laws.

“In support of these sweeping and premature arguments, plaintiffs regularly misstate the parties’ negotiations, defendants’ positions, and the discovery practice concerning foreign data privacy laws in this (New York court) District,” they claimed.

They told the court that the defendants have not sought a protective order that would enable them to redact any information from documents that would be defined as foreign personal data.

“Nor have defendants taken the position that ’employee names and other professional contact information be redacted from discovery material’, as plaintiffs contend,” the airline’s lawyers insisted.

The defendants’ lawyers said they now expect that information such as names and titles will be disclosed in documents, except in “narrow circumstances” where such data is not necessary or relevant to the litigation.

Irish Independent

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

Stay Connected

16,985FansLike
2,458FollowersFollow
61,453SubscribersSubscribe

Must Read

Jinger Duggar’s husband Jeremy Vuolo called ‘pretentious’ by fans after he shares ‘lost art of writing letters’ post

JINGER Duggar's husband Jeremy Vuolo was called "pretentious" by fans for highlighting the "lost art of writing letters."Jeremy, 33, shared a photo holding a...
- Advertisement -

Protests in Poland over court’s ruling on abortion

Police in Poland used pepper spray and arrested 15 people during protests against a ruling by the country's Supreme Court that could end...

Biden aims to jettison Trump’s ‘America First’ policy

Every election, reduced to essentials, boils down to voters deciding between continuity and change. oes it seem right to keep going in a particular...

Trump goes for broke but Biden stands firm in vital last debate

With time running out and trailing in the polls, President Donald Trump needed the strongest possible showing in his final debate against Joe Biden....

Related News

Jinger Duggar’s husband Jeremy Vuolo called ‘pretentious’ by fans after he shares ‘lost art of writing letters’ post

JINGER Duggar's husband Jeremy Vuolo was called "pretentious" by fans for highlighting the "lost art of writing letters."Jeremy, 33, shared a photo holding a...

Protests in Poland over court’s ruling on abortion

Police in Poland used pepper spray and arrested 15 people during protests against a ruling by the country's Supreme Court that could end...

Biden aims to jettison Trump’s ‘America First’ policy

Every election, reduced to essentials, boils down to voters deciding between continuity and change. oes it seem right to keep going in a particular...

Trump goes for broke but Biden stands firm in vital last debate

With time running out and trailing in the polls, President Donald Trump needed the strongest possible showing in his final debate against Joe Biden....

Voracious mutant crayfish pose ecological threat to historic cemetery

Self-cloning mutant crayfish created in experimental breeding programmes have invaded a Belgian cemetery. Hundreds of the duplicating crustaceans, which can dig down to up...
- Advertisement -

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

%d bloggers like this: